Tuesday, December 8, 2020

Bidding Question

Hi Heidi,

We came across a hand that we didn't know how to bid today:

EW Vulnerable, N is dealer:

North
♠QT82
♥4
♦K976
♣Q764
West
♠A7
♥Q7
♦A53
♣AKT985
East
♠95
♥KT85
♦QJ42
♣J32
South
♠KJ643
♥AJ9632
♦T8
♣

N E S W
Pass Pass 2♥ 3♣
Pass Pass ???

Question: Should South have bid 3♠?

Heidi's Answer


"6-5 Come ALIVE! Bid until you are Doubled, Game or Slam!" was one on my mom's favourite sayings. This hand certainly qualifies!

I would say the South hand is just TOO good to open a weak 2 with that distribution. They should either open at the 1 level (which is fine since they are in third seat) or potentially "Pass" and come in later. Since they are in 3rd seat I would open the bidding for sure. (If Partner wasn't a passed hand I still might open at the 1 level but I also might "Pass" and hope to show a distributional hand with majors later on. Depends on my mood. Certainly the colours are right for bidding.)

But in third seat open at the 1 level. You are allowed to (even encouraged to!) open weaker hands in third seat.

But what to open?

If you open 1♥ you risk not being able to show your ♠ suit. If Partner bids 1NT, bidding 2♠ is a reverse showing a strong distributional hand.

Another option is to open 1♠ and rebid 2♥ showing a 5-4 or 5-5 hand depending on the auction. But this will never get across to Partner you have longer ♥.

Unfortunately you have to make a choice. But fortunately I think either bid works here.

If South opens 1♥, West will probably bid 2♣. Now North can Double to show ♠ and ♦ (Negative Double). East will bid 3♣ but South can now bid either 3♠ (minimum) or 4♠ (if they realize the potential of their 6-5.) After a 3♠ bid by South the Opponents might compete with 4♣ -- West is very strong -- but that just might push N/S into their 4♠ game.

If South opens 1♠, West will probably bid 2♣. Now North will show some sort of ♠ raise. Either a limit raise (with a 3♣ bid) or a simple raise with a 2♠ bid. After a limit raise South should bid game on their distribution alone. After a simple raise of 2♠, East will bid 3♣ and South can make a game try with 3♥. West might bid 4♣ but even if they don't, North should bid 4♠ since they can help stop the ♥ losers with their singleton and extra trump.

If West bids to 5♣ North should certainly DOUBLE them. PENALTY.

South might have some stressful moments with the Double (after all they don't have many points and/or tricks with all their bidding) but should trust their partner and sit for it. Partner should only count on them for having a distributional hand with the majors which is exactly what they have.

If South leads a ♠ the Defence will certainly take this contract down three for 800 points. Even a lead of their singleton ♥ should take the contract down two for 500. Either one makes up for the NS game (420).

Suggested Auction

I think South should just open 1♠ in third set. You plan on telling Partner you have the majors and let them choose which one to play in. I'd hate to give up on the ♠ suit by opening 1♥.

North will probably just give a simple raise to 2♠.

South can now show their ♥ suit looking for a potential game. 6-5 Come Alive!

North should bid the game with their singleton ♥ and extra trump.

West will probably be in there since they do have quite a strong hand. Sometimes points do not equal tricks unfortunately! I assume they will try to defeat the Opponents rather than bidding 5♣. If they do decide to bid 5♣ North should DOUBLE and West will be sorry.

North
♠QT82
♥4
♦K976
♣Q764
West
♠A7
♥Q7
♦A53
♣AKT985
East
♠95
♥KT85
♦QJ42
♣J32
South
♠KJ643
♥AJ9632
♦T8
♣

N E S W
Pass Pass 1♠ 2♣
2♠ 3♣ 3♥ 4♣
4♠ Pass Pass Pass

Friday, December 4, 2020

Hand 10 -- 1NT vs 1 Major

This is chapter 10 in the story of my attempt to determine if it is better to open 1♠ or 1NT with 15 to 17 HCP and a five card ♠ suit.

The journey started with this post:
Later On

Here is the tenth hand I generated:

Dealer: East North
♠Q
♥Q87
♦K42
♣QJT765
West
♠T832
♥K53
♦J653
♣92
East
♠AKJ95
♥642
♦AT7
♣A4
South
♠764
♥AJT9
♦Q98
♣K83

Dealer is East and everyone vulnerable.

Double Dummy:
3♠ can make by E/W
1NT can make by E/W


Analysis

If East opens up 1NT I think West will "Pass" and North might find a way to show their ♣ suit. No matter how they do this I think East will now bid 2♠. South can raise Partner's ♣ suit. West can raise Partner's ♠ suit. LAW level.

What happens if North opens 1♠?

West will "Pass". Will North balance in with 2♣?

If they do, West should compete (LAW level) so you will end up with the same result.

However if North does not come into either auction then East is better off opening 1♠ since ♠ takes 9 tricks and NT takes only 7. So this hand is better off opening 1♠.

How does ♠ do realistically?

Declarer should find 8 tricks pretty easily and it is easy to let the Opponent's in and make them play ♦ for you for the ninth trick.

1NT is a little tougher to get that ninth trick. Plus if the Opponents get into ♣... If South leads a ♥ I assume Declarer will just take their eight tricks. Not a lot of ways to make nine tricks in NT.

To see the table where all the hands are listed click HERE!

Monday, November 30, 2020

Real Life Hand

Hi Heidi,

In the hand below, South considered three possible bids, 2♠, 2NT and 3♦, each had its shortcomings. What is your analysis and recommendation?

EW vulnerable, East is dealer:

North
♠432
♥T92
♦62
♣QJ982
West
♠JT8
♥KQ6
♦T98743
♣7
East
♠K9
♥J8543
♦J
♣AK653
South
♠AQ765
♥A7
♦AKQ5
♣T4

N E S W
1♣ 1♠ Pass
Pass 2♥ ???


Heidi's Answer

First of all I don't really like the auction so far. I don't like any of the bids. But we can discuss that later.

I think at this point South should be bidding 3♦ if they are going to bid. Give Partner a choice of suits.

I don't want to rebid my ♠ suit since I already told Partner I had five of them. I don't want to bid 2NT with no stopper in ♣ plus if Partner is very weak (which they should be in this auction!) NT will not be a fun place to play!

So if South bids 3♦, North will bid 3♠. They prefer that suit.

South knows that Partner couldn't even raise their 1♠ bid to 2♠ showing 6 to 10 points. They either don't have a fit or don't have any points. They will "Pass" 3♠.

The Result?

On this hand North/South can take 8 tricks in ♠. They should go down in 3♠.

On this hand East/West can take 8 tricks in ♥. They should go down in 3♥.

How should the bidding go?

If East is going to open the bidding they should open the bidding 1♥. Yes their ♣ suit is much better but with two five card suits you bid the higher ranking suit first always. Always always always. Both Opener, Responder and even Overcaller!

With 19 HCP South can start with a "Double". This is the "BIG Double" to show a hand too strong to overcall! (But no one at the table knows this yet! Right now it just looks like a normal Take Out Double!)

West will bid 2♥. They have 6 to 10 points and a fit for Partner's major.

North would have had to bid over South's Take Out Double but West bid and took them off the hook. They are quite happy to "Pass".

East will "Pass".

South will now bid 2♠ to show a hand TOO STRONG to just overcall 1♠.

West will "Pass".

North will probably just "Pass". I like to raise Partner (if I can!) when they Double and bid their suit with not many points at all but this hand is too weak and balanced for me to want to say anything.

Will East compete to 3♥? With two five card suits they just might.

South will probably Double to show a very strong hand. They have lots of tricks.

Will North leave the Double in? Or will they bid 3♠ since they have support? Who knows. I would say with no tricks in their hand and support for Partner they will probably bid. But with these colours (E/W are VULNERABLE!) they might "Pass" and hope they go down.