Monday, November 23, 2020

Hand 9 -- 1NT vs 1 Major

This is chapter 9 in the story of my attempt to determine if it is better to open 1♠ or 1NT with 15 to 17 HCP and a five card ♠ suit.

The journey started with this post:
Later On

Here is the ninth hand I generated:

Dealer: North North
♠KQT93
♥AJ6
♦KT
♣QJ3
West
♠AJ85
♥KQT
♦A87
♣864
East
♠6
♥9432
♦J943
♣KT92
South
♠742
♥875
♦Q652
♣A75

Dealer is North and East/West are vulnerable.

Double Dummy:
2♠ can make by N/S
1NT can make by N/S


Analysis

If North opens up 1NT I think they will play it there. South does not have enough to respond and the Opponents don't have a suit they can play in.

What happens if North opens 1♠?

Most newer players do not play constructive raises. They will get too high. South will respond 2♠ and North with their better than minimum hand will try for a game. They will stop in 3♠ but 3♠ goes down easily. There is only one Dummy entry. Sadness.

Even if you do play constructive raises it is hard to play this hand for the eight tricks needed to make 2♠.

I'm going to say this is a hand better off if North opens the bidding 1NT.

To see the table where all the hands are listed click HERE!

Friday, November 20, 2020

Hand 8 -- 1NT vs 1 Major

This is chapter 8 in the story of my attempt to determine if it is better to open 1♠ or 1NT with 15 to 17 HCP and a five card ♠ suit.

The journey started with this post:
Later On

Here is the eighth hand I generated:

Dealer: West North
♠84
♥A97532
♦QJ
♣963
West
♠AJ973
♥KQ
♦AK3
♣752
East
♠Q2
♥J864
♦T9865
♣AJ
South
♠KT65
♥T
♦742
♣KQT84

Dealer is West and everyone is vulnerable.

Double Dummy:
4NT can make by E/W


Analysis

If West opens up 1NT, North will pass and what will East do? Do they have enough to invite?

I think they do. They have 8 HCP and a five card suit. If you use the Rule of 16 it will tell you to go.

So East will bid Stayman. South might "Double" to get a ♣ lead.

West will probably bid 2♠ since they do have a five card suit.

East will now either bid 2NT (which West will raise to 3NT since they are MAXIMUM) or bid 3NT themselves.

What happens if West opens 1♠?

East will respond 1NT and West with their 17 HCP will raise to 2NT. East will bid 3NT.

South will lead the K♣.

So this one I think the result will be the same. 3NT will be reached no matter what West opens. They will get a ♣ lead no matter what.

To see the table where all the hands are listed click HERE!

Sunday, November 15, 2020

Real Life Hand

Hi Heidi,

In the hand below, how should West bid? 1♠ or 1NT? What is your analysis and recommendation?

All vulnerable, East is dealer:

North
♠T8543
♥83
♦982
♣K64
West
♠AKJ9
♥A752
♦J6
♣QT7
East
♠762
♥94
♦AQT54
♣J52
South
♠Q
♥KQJT6
♦K73
♣A983

N E S W
Pass 1♥ ???


Heidi's Answer

I don't hate overcalling on a strong four card suit but I do try to avoid it so on this hand I probably would overcall 1NT to show my 15 to 18 HCP with a balanced hand. 1NT just gets across my strength and balanced shape. I would bid 1♠ with a much worse, much more distributional hand. So that would be my choice on this hand.

The Result?

On this hand North/South can take 7 tricks in ♥ and ♣.

East/West can take 9 tricks in ♦ and 7 tricks in ♠.

If West makes a 1♠ overcall North will "Pass" and East will raise to 2♠. The auction will likely end there. If North/South want to try to bid they will get too high and go down too many!

If West makes a 1NT overcall North will "Pass" and East will "Pass". Will South let them play in 1NT? They should at these colours.

East/West can go down 1 trick in 1NT. I think they will. North will lead a ♥. West will try the ♦ finesse which will lose. After South takes all their ♥ winners they will switch to their next best suit -- ♣ -- and take the next two tricks. Down 1.

Hard for East to bid ♦ on this hand.

So unless South does something crazy when vulnerable, E/W will get the contract and go down no matter what West bids.